Dear
Caroline: This is America ( A Discussion)
Written
By: Theoren Heilman
All throughout today's world there are so many social
issues that are such necessities to be tackled but there is one bug in us all
that prevents them from being addressed. This is our lovely friend confirmation
bias, the idea that it couldn’t possibly be “that bad” or “Well I don't do that”.
Our own mind lets us completely negate the fact that there is a struggle going
on simply because of our own inherent biases. Despite this fact we can address
issues in a more productive way when we take ourselves out of the situation.
When we have a vantage point and look in at ourselves, in almost an out of body
experience, we tend to be able to look at things in a much more productive
manner. One very prominent and repugnant issue that is still around today is
racism. When we address prominent social
issues we tend to come directly at one another rather than the idea od the
issue itself. This is extremely true with racism as anybody would do anything
in order to avoid the term of being a racist. With this being said, when we
take ourselves out of the situation and look at it from a distance it is much
easier to address the issue as a whole rather than attack one another back and
forth. This is seen in the recently published “This is America” video by artist
Childish Gambino. This video has not quite a Science Fiction feel but falls
under a hyper realistic realm of fantasy including figures from all parts of
history in the same spot which gives it this almost fantasy feel. Gambino
provides a set of characters that we would conclude our human based on their
actions and their looks but are placed in an environment that is relatable to
almost nobody. After meer minutes of the video being on the internet, it poured
out hundreds of comments and videos with both reactions and addressing the
issues being presented by the video. Rather than having people argue over the
idea of racism people analyzed the video picking out specific instances of
racism that could be identified or hinted at. I believe that a Speculative
fiction story could easily have the same effect on readers that this video had
on its viewers. If readers were to come into contact with a story with a high
fantasy setting or plot but real world incidents disguised by the fantasy it
could greatly distance the reader but still address the topic at hand. It is
very difficult for many people to have argument based discussions as many
people get uncomfortable with the idea of conflict or possibly being the reason
it is happening. By giving the reader disguised situations that they may or may
not have taken place in before but can understand it takes out this idea of
confirmation bias and conflict. This is exactly what happened in “This is
America”, as Gambino distanced the reader by creating a fake situation but
addressing disguised real world issues into the video itself. I believe that
Speculative Fiction could easily be a gateway into more understanding and the
destruction of confirmation biases by creating a neutral platform on which
these texts address issues without addressing specific people. Thank you, and
goodnight.
https://genius.com/Childish-gambino-this-is-america-lyrics
Theo,
ReplyDeleteI think your post (which can be a little difficult to follow in places, as the ideas are more streamed together than broken down into phases of analysis or response) presents a reasonable reiteration of what confirmation bias is, but I'm not sure that it precisely answers the issue of how SF is positioned to address this specifically and in the face of what issues. An exegesis of "This is America" as a kind of sf piece dismantling expectations (and perhaps also confirmation bias) would be really interesting.
Best,
TT